Skip To Content

A Jury Trial in the Age of COVID

November 13, 2020

by Samuel J. DeBlasis, II

When I realized my scheduled jury trial was going to go forward last week, I would be lying if I said I wasn’t concerned. I was. With COVID statistics on the rise and the Governor back tracking on moves to reopen, I’ll admit I was a bit more than nervous. However, sometimes, in instances as this, you have to do the best you can and take a leap of faith that everything will be alright. All things considered, my overall experience was good and that the process used by the Anne Arundel County Circuit Court works as best as can be expected under the circumstances.

The jury trial was to commence last Thursday November 5th and last two days. Throughout the week before I expected a call at any time from the assignment office telling me the trial would have to be postponed. The call never came and on Thursday morning I appeared with witnesses ready to go. We were met on the sidewalk outside the courthouse by sheriffs who took our temperatures and asked a series of questions about how we felt and whether we had been exposed.  The courthouse was not crowded. Everyone was wearing masks and benches were clearly marked with areas where sitting was and was not allowed. 

The case was on the “to be assigned” docket but the wait was less than an hour before we were sent to a large courtroom with no less than 50 prospective jurors waiting, all properly socially distanced throughout the courtroom and all wearing masks. Judge Stacy McCormack moved swiftly and efficiently through voir dire. Jurors who had responses to questions were asked only their number and then asked to sit down. When all of the questions were completed, the judge and attorneys moved to another smaller courtroom where jurors with responses were admitted, one by one, to reveal their answers. Once that process was complete, we moved back to the larger courtroom where final jury selection occurred. From that point, the six jurors, one alternate, and attorneys and clients all went to yet another courtroom to commence the trial before trial Judge Robert Thompson.

Three jurors sat in front of the jury box and were separated by Plexiglas behind them from three more jurors in the jury box with more Plexiglas separating the final juror behind them. Attorneys sat at tables separated by at least one and sometimes two Plexiglas panels. The clerk was behind Plexiglas and the witnesses were behind Plexiglas. Everyone wore masks and no one seemed to have any difficulty hearing anyone. Everyone was respectful of social distancing but attorneys were able to move around the courtroom. The trial proceeded from beginning to end without incident. When the jury deliberated, they stayed in the courtroom and used the area to socially distance while everyone else stayed outside.

I must admit, under the circumstances, I felt the court handled the whole matter safely and efficiently. The only time it crossed my mind that I might have a potential for exposure was

at bench conferences. Although we all were wearing masks and trying to keep our distance, that didn’t always occur. I believe that in other courtrooms there are provisions for remote bench conferences but not in ours. Nonetheless, I was very familiar with opposing counsel and comfortable with the judge, our conferences were very short, and I did not feel uncomfortable.

At the end of the process I felt everyone was doing the best they could to help prevent the spread of the virus. I think I was most impressed by the fact that, at no time did I get the impression from either the voir dire jury panel or the eventual jury that they were anymore mad, scared, or annoyed they had to be there than any usual jury who has to sit through two days of trial and hours of testimony from two medical experts.

Now we are about a week out from the jury verdict finding favorably for my client. I have no hint of symptoms and am not aware of any contact tracing attempts from the courthouse. Although I understand that Maryland courts have once again suspended jury trials due to the uptick in COVID cases, my experience left me with the notion that, with the proper precautions, which I believe were taken in this case by everyone – judge, jurors, attorneys and courthouse personnel – we can cautiously proceed forward under the new normal to move cases through the system.